Unsure About Adopting, I Tried Fostering First

One pet parent wasn’t quite sure if this cat was the right fit for her—so she chose the thoughtful, no-pressure path: fostering to adopt.

A fluffy, black-and-white tuxedo cat with expressive eyes sitting calmly on a sunlit windowsill

Animal rescuers first encountered Domino—an aptly named kitty with a perfectly cute Rorschach-inkblot face and cotton-ball paws—on the streets of Jamaica, Queens. It was the fall of 2002, and he was about to be left behind as his mom was being rescued. Domino bounded toward the rescue car, refusing to be overlooked. Despite his persistence, his mom found a loving home quickly—while Domino remained without one.

Around the same time, a potential cat parent in New York City felt uncertain about whether she was ready to commit to pet parenthood. “Since I was only looking to adopt one cat, it was also tricky to find a pet that was a good fit for what I was looking for,” she says—until she discovered Domino on furpetvo.com. “Then I saw Domino. He’s such a sweet, friendly cat, and I’m so glad that I was able to find him when I did.”

That initial hesitation wasn’t a sign of doubt—it was wisdom in action. Impulsive adoption decisions, made without adequate preparation, can lead to heartbreaking outcomes: pets surrendered to shelters (risking trauma or even euthanasia) or rehomed under stressful circumstances. Taking time to reflect—and to truly get to know a pet—isn’t just responsible. It’s deeply ethical.

Fostering to Adopt: A Thoughtful First Step

“The independent shelter that had found him was looking for a new foster for him, and they offered me a ‘foster-to-adopt’ situation,” she explains. Fostering to adopt is a compassionate, low-risk way to explore pet parenthood. It starts as a short-term commitment: you welcome a pet into your home, help them adjust to domestic life, and learn firsthand about their personality, habits, and needs.

If the match feels right, you adopt. If not, you continue caring for them while sharing valuable insights with the shelter—helping them find the perfect forever family. Either way, it’s a win-win: the cat thrives outside the shelter environment, and staff gain precious bandwidth to support more animals in need.

A person gently holding a young tuxedo kitten wrapped in a soft blanket, both looking calm and connected

When Domino arrived at his new home, “he was very talkative and scared—and cried the whole night. He needed to be wrapped up in a blanket and rocked with music in the background to calm down.” A rocky start is completely normal for any cat adjusting to a new, unfamiliar space. Yet the bond formed quickly. “Within a few days, I knew he was my forever friend.”

Building a Life Together, One Day at a Time

Today, they’re inseparable. “By the end of our first weekend together, Domino was starting to get accustomed to his new home—and now, one-and-a-half years later, he needs to be in the room I’m in at all times. He loves greeting me whenever I come home from an adventure,” she shares.

“Every night we have our nighttime cuddles, and if I’m having a late night, he’ll meow at me, letting me know, ‘Hey, it’s time for bed.’”

Domino curled up asleep on a cozy couch next to a pair of slippers and a book, bathed in warm afternoon light

FurPetVo connects hopeful pet parents with shelters, rescues, and rehomers—so more adoptable pets can find their people. Ready to begin your journey? Start your pet adoption search today at furpetvo.com.

A smiling person sitting on the floor, gently petting Domino as he leans into the touch, both relaxed and happy